Helmets: Safe or Symbolic

The bike helmet, it’s certainly an emotive issue amongst cyclists and seemingly one with no simple answer. There are many for and against advocates who constantly voice strong opinions on the matter and equally there is much evidence to back up both sides of the argument. So who is right? There is no doubt a helmet can reduce the risk of severe head injuries and even death but this is very dependent on the type of accident, let’s be honest a helmet will do nothing if you tangle with a lorry, it’s simply not designed for such high impact collisions.

Even though every club I know or have dealt with has a compulsory helmet policy, there is currently no legislation within the UK that requires you to wear a helmet; it is purely down to individual choice. Like most UK and Irish cycling clubs, VC Iveagh employ a zero tolerance rule when it comes to helmet safety with the remit that it’s better being safe than sorry. However, there is no way to enforce this policy when riders are out on solo training runs. So, why enforce a policy for group rides if the decision is down to individual choice?

Recently one of our members crashed while out on a group ride, unfortunately it was a case of touching wheels with an estimated speed of between 20-25mph. The rider went down with the left side of his helmet taking the brunt of the impact, not one person in the club has or had any doubt that the injury would have been a lot more serious if a helmet had not be worn. The helmet in question was a Giro Aeon and it basically took the impact upon hitting the tarmac. As you can see from the images below, the externals and internals of the helmet broke apart while absorbing the impact and cushioning the blow to the head, exactly what a helmet is supposed to do. So while there are neurosurgeons who suggest wearing a helmet will give you no protection whatsoever, I have seen enough accidents in my time spent on the roads to completely disagree.

hel1

hel2

hel3

Rather than preaching the rights and wrongs of wearing a helmet, we would suggest you take the time to do a little research into the subject matter. There are a plethora of sites that try and validate the pros and cons of helmet safety with some industry big hitters like Bradley Wiggins and Chris Boardman becoming embroiled in the matter. There is no doubt that safety benefits do exist when wearing a helmet but they must be taken as a whole, if you ride safely rather than depending on protective gear you will significantly increase your chances of staying safe.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Helmets: Safe or Symbolic

  1. Having hit the deck last winter after hitting a patch of ice & not having time to react, it was my head that broke my fall & then 3yrs ago whilst mountain biking, head 1st into a tree stump was my preferred method of braking. I have no doubt that the helmet stopped further injury. I was knocked out cold from the MTB incident & I broke the helmet strap attachment from the ice mishap…no helmet & I reckon on both occasions I wasn’t getting back on the bike in a hurry!

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s